Skip to main content

Colts vs. Giants Odds, Picks, Predictions Week 17: Fade the Public Narrative

Kenny Ducey

Last Updated: January 1, 2023 6:52 AM EST • 2 min 29 sec read.

The New York Giants are playing to earn a playoff spot when they welcome the Indianapolis Colts to New Jersey in Week 17. We break down a big game with our Colts vs. Giants NFL picks based on the best odds.

The Colts’ season has been over for a while now, but they’ll have a golden opportunity to play spoiler on Sunday against a team searching for a playoff spot.

With a win, the Giants can clinch a spot in the playoffs. The issue? They’ve recorded just one of those in their last six games.

Here is our best Colts vs. Giants NFL pick for Week 17 (odds via ; pick confidence based on a 1-to-5-star scale).

Check out our NFL best bets and all of our top NFL picks for Week 17.

Colts vs. Giants Game Info

Date: Sunday, Jan. 1, 1 p.m. ET
TV: CBS
Location: MetLife Stadium, East Rutherford, NJ
Weather: 54 degrees, 10% chance of precipitation, 10-mph wins

Colts vs. Giants Odds

Colts vs. Giants Odds Analysis

The Giants opened as 4.5-point favorites and have quickly become the favorite side of many bettors. New York is out to a 5.5-point favorite as of Friday evening, thanks to some pretty heavy splits. is reporting a whopping 78% of the tickets and 81% of the handle is on the home side.

The Under appears to be a sharp play with 54% of the bets and 80% of the handle coming in on that side of the total. The opening number of 40.5 is long gone and some shops are even down to 38.5.

Editor's note: Hey Ohio! Welcome to legal sports betting. Check out the best sites for Ohio sports betting and the best Ohio sportsbook promos!  

Colts vs. Giants Pick

Colts +6 ⭐⭐⭐⭐

It’s hard to look strictly at common opponents for this matchup given the Colts are going to be without running back Jonathan Taylor in this game and have made changes at head coach and quarterback. With that said, Indianapolis managed to cover a spread of 3.5 points a couple of weeks ago against the Minnesota Vikings, and the Giants covered 4.5 against Minnesota last week. Both teams lost on late field goals.

With that, it’s a bit of a stretch to say the Giants are six points better than the Colts, even at home. For starters, MetLife Stadium has never proven to be a huge edge for the teams it hosts. Second, this is not a very good Giants team.

Say what you will about the Colts, but they can at least lay claim to the eighth-best defense in the league according to weighted DVOA. The Giants are down in 31st. Offensively, New York is mediocre at best, ranking 15th in DVOA, while Indy has had well-documented struggles.

I think Colts QB Nick Foles started to hit his stride in the third and fourth quarter of last week’s loss to the Los Angeles Chargers after starting the game miserably. Against a sorry defense on Sunday, this could easily turn into a close game. I’m willing to fade the public and the team with everything to play for in exchange for an Indy team that has looked somewhat competent a couple of times under head coach Jeff Saturday.

Colts vs. Giants Best Odds

BetMGM (-110)

DraftKingsFanDuelBetMGMCaesarsPointsBet
+5.5+5.5+5.5+5.5+5.5
-110-110-110-110-110

BetMGM held on longer than the other sportsbooks at a 6-point line, but has since joined with every other shop hanging 5.5 points. The market appears to have settled in full agreement.

Colts-Giants pick made 12/30/2022 at 10:19 p.m. ET.

Here are our Best NFL Betting Sites:

* Bonuses not applicable in Ontario.

Related Pages

Best Online Sportsbooks | Best U.S. Sportsbook Promos

Written By:
Kenny Ducey
Kenny is a contributor for DraftKings and a former member of the Baseball Writers' Association of America. He's covered Tennis, Football, Basketball, and Baseball dating back to his time at Sports Illustrated. He's based out of New York, where sports have taken a turn for the worst, yet somehow his support for the Jets and Knicks has not wavered in the slightest.