Skip to main content

Bryce Young vs. C.J. Stroud Betting Odds & Predictions: Which NFL Rookie QB Will Shine?

Shane Jackson

Last Updated: June 20, 2023 8:55 AM EDT • 3 min 2 sec read.

Rookie quarterbacks Bryce Young and C.J. Stroud are ready to roll after being the top picks in the 2023 NFL Draft, but which signal caller will have more success in Year 1? Read on as we analyze Young vs. Stroud props based on the latest NFL odds from our best sports betting apps.

Quarterbacks Bryce Young and C.J. Stroud were the first names to be called in the 2023 NFL Draft, with the former going No. 1 overall to the Carolina Panthers and the latter being selected by the Houston Texas with the No. 2 pick. These quarterbacks will now be compared to each other for the rest of their careers. That is simply how things work in the NFL.

Young and Stroud can help themselves by setting the tone with a strong rookie campaign. Both signal callers are likely to start the majority of the regular-season games for their respective teams, which is why they opened near the top of the Offensive Rookie of the Year oddsboard.

But is giving bettors the chance to have even more action on these two quarterbacks with head-to-head player props for Young vs. Stroud. Between passing yards and passing touchdowns, there are multiple season matchups worth playing if you know which quarterback to back.

Let's take a look at the Young vs. Stroud season matchups via our best sports betting sites to figure out the best betting angle ahead of the 2023-24 NFL campaign.

Head-to-head passing yards

QuarterbackDraftKings
Bryce Young-120
C.J. Stroud-110

As expected, Young has a slight edge to finish his rookie season with more passing yards than Stroud. You have to pay -120 odds to take the No. 1 overall pick in this head-to-head matchup, which comes out to an implied probability of 54.55%. 

Of all the Young vs. Stroud markets, this is the best bet for my money. projects Young to finish with roughly 3,643 passing yards in Year 1, which is comfortably ahead of Stroud's projection of approximately 3,463 passing yards.

Mike Clay of ESPN recently released his  for fantasy football, in which he has Young throwing for 3,560 yards and Stroud tossing 3,328 yards.

Both Young and Stroud are listed at 80/1 to be the NFL's passing yards leader this season, which is obviously unlikely. But we believe Young steps into a more favorable situation on Day 1, and that should lead to better production in Year 1.

Andrew Luck holds the record for most passing yards by a rookie, as he finished with 4,374 yards through the air in 2012 for the Indianapolis Colts.

Embed content drNTQ70HKlw image

Head-to-head passing touchdowns

QuarterbackDraftKings
Bryce Young-120
C.J. Stroud-110

Similar to the passing yards matchup, Young is a -120 favorite to finish with more passing touchdowns than Stroud this season.

Stroud recorded 85 touchdowns in his collegiate career at Ohio State, while Young tossed 80 scores through the air at Alabama. And there might be some value on Stroud in this market. According to Clay's projections, both quarterbacks will throw 18 passing touchdowns in 15 games.

The reason we prefer to stray from this market is because touchdowns tend to be a bit fluky. Carolina is projected to have a better offense, which could lead to more scores, but I'm not sure I'm confident enough in that assessment at these odds.

The record for most passing touchdowns in a rookie season belongs to Justin Herbert, who tossed 31 scores during his 2020 campaign with the Los Angeles Chargers.

Embed content OPpVZZwpqkw image

Rookie of the Year odds

QuarterbackDraftKingsFanDuelBetMGMCaesarsPointsBet
Bryce Young+500 🔥+450+450+400 ❄️+450
C.J. Stroud+750+900 🔥+650+650+700

For the best payout on the top rookie quarterbacks, consider betting them in the Offensive Rookie of the Year market. A quarterback has not won this award since 2020, but 11 different signal callers have been named OROY in NFL history.

In this case, DraftKings has the best deal on Young while offers the best price on Stroud.

You can also take advantage of the team specials market at DraftKings for more potential wagers on either quarterback. All 32 teams are featured in their own tab under team specials on your mobile app.

For example, Young is +150 to throw for 400-plus yards in any regular-season game during his rookie year. Young only accomplished this feat in three of his 34 collegiate appearances, including a career-best 559 yards against Arkansas.

Here are our best NFL betting sites:

(21+. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER)
* Bonuses not applicable in Ontario.

Related pages

Written By:
Shane Jackson
Shane Jackson has been writing for Sportsbook Review since 2022, though his passion for sports, writing, and betting runs much longer than that. He graduated from the University of Kansas with a journalism degree in 2017 and has been covering sports ever since, working for MLB.com, Manhattan Mercury, Lawrence Journal-World, WynnBET, Bet Chicago Sports, BetNOLA, and BetMGM. Jackson cares about creating quality sports betting content above all else. He uses a mixture of models, information, film, analysis, and a top-down approach to locate every best bet shared for SBR. He never gives out a pick that he wouldn’t be willing to spend his own money on. Jackson is focused on finding +EV bets on a daily basis for a variety of sports such as NCAAF, NCAAB, NFL, NBA, WNBA, and MLB. He usually bets on props but is willing to wager on a spread or total when there is an edge. Don’t ask him how many bets he has placed on a typical college football Saturday. Jackson doesn’t care if you follow him on social media, but his Twitter account has info on how you can follow his bets through multiple third-party platforms. He just wants you to read all the great work from the SBR team.